Rewarding Teachers

Day 82: Working with Another TeacherImage by Old Shoe Woman via Flickr

If you care to look you will find dozens of articles just like this one. Articles about states passing laws requiring teachers to show improvements in student test scores or lose their jobs.

First, I think it should be obvious, but it isn't, that one test per year is just bad science. We need a real way to measure teacher performance, preferably based on a combination of several metrics.

Second, if we pass a law like this how is that going to play out in the classroom?

  • Who is going to take the IEP students?

    • “Not I”, said the teacher with 10 years of seniority.

  • Who is going to take the disruptive students?

    • “Not I”, said the team leaders

    • “I'll send that disruptive child to the office everyday before 8:01 so I can teach the other 29 students in my classroom.” Said the teacher who got stuck with them.

  • Who is going to work in the worst schools?

    • “Not I”, said the teacher who wants to feed his children and pay the mortgage next year.

  • Who is going to fix the problems of poverty, gangs, poor parenting, and drugs that are out of the control of the teachers?

    • “Not I”, said the politician who really could care less.

In Time Magazine there was an article recently about motivating students. Many folks were in a big uproar because they felt this was paying for grades. Unfortunately that was about as far of the mark as you could get. In reality paying students to get A's or B's (though a time honored tradition among parents) had almost no effect at all. What did affect students grades was to pay (or reward) students for doing something they could control that we know will help improve their grades. Like reading books, or finishing homework, or showing up on time ready to go, or NOT disrupting class.


Let me repeat that, REWARDING STUDENTS FOR DOING SOMETHING THEY COULD CONTROL THAT WE KNOW WILL HELP IMPROVE THEIR GRADES.


Uh, duh. So how do we reward teachers for doing something that will improve their teaching and that they can control?


Related articles by Zemanta
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Making Myself a Better Teacher Episode 1

My first podcast with a friend Joy Kirr. The audio file  Podcast page Joy is a local teacher whom I was following on Twitter. I don't think I even realized she was local when I first started following her. One day she tweeted out an activity she was hosting at the school she worked at the time. I was like, hey that's right down the road I should go. And so I did, with my wife and kids in tow we went. I just really love making these connections.  We haven't talked much in the last few years but when I decided to start this podcast series and I was trying to think of teachers that I would like to chat with I remembered Joy and thought, "Yes, she is a teacher I would like to learn from." So here we are with my first episode.  As I reviewed to the chat I thought I would mark down some of the parts I thought were good. Around minute 3 we talk about low and high points in education and she really embodies a growth mindset. Keep those keepsakes,
Read more

Writing my lessons with OpenAI

Image
 Good unit plans require backward planning so let's create an assessment. Write a performance task for the mathematical standard Solve linear equations in one variable. Performance Task: Linear Equation Word Problems You have been hired by a furniture company to help them price their products. The company has determined that the price of a table is directly proportional to its length. They have found that a 6 foot long table costs $300. You are given the following information: The cost of a table is directly proportional to its length A 6 foot long table costs $300 Using this information, you need to answer the following questions: Write an equation that represents the relationship between the length of a table (in feet) and its cost (in dollars). A customer wants to purchase a 9 foot long table. How much will it cost? The company wants to sell a 4 foot long table for $200. Is this possible, and if so, what will the cost be? To complete this task, you will need to use your knowledg
Read more

Finally getting around to playing with CHATGPT

 My first question and answer. so the question is from a performance task I set for my students. I think if they followed the directions they could turn in a piece of work that I would grade as acceptable. Often I try to get my students to write or verbally explain their thought process and I would be looking for this exact answer. Well maybe I would expect them to tell me to draw a line up three boxes on a graph paper and over 4 boxes to make a right triangle. Draw a right triangle ABC.side lengths of 3 and 4. Draw a dilation of triangle ABC with a center of dilation at A and a scale factor of 2 label the new vertices B’ and C’ Write a similarity statement for triangles ABC and AB’C’ To draw a right triangle with side lengths 3 and 4, start by drawing a horizontal line and a vertical line. These two lines will represent two sides of the triangle. Next, draw a diagonal line connecting the two lines to form the hypotenuse of the triangle. Label the points where the horizontal and
Read more